Why Was Jesus Forced to Carry His Cross?
Roman practice generally required condemned prisoners to carry the crossbeam (patibulum) of their own cross to the execution site. This was further punishment and intentional public humiliation, part of reinforcing the message to onlookers that opposition to Rome would end in one’s own horrific death. It was also a practical matter, since the upright post was often left standing at the execution ground.
All four Gospels describe Jesus carrying his cross, at least initially. The Synoptic gospels then describe Simon of Cyrene being compelled by Roman soldiers to carry it for him, suggesting that Jesus, after scourging, was physically unable to continue. Roman scourging before crucifixion was a severe punishment in itself: a multi-tailed whip (flagrum), usually embedded with metal or bone, caused significant blood loss and trauma, A prisoner might often be unable to carry such a load: accounts of the time suggest that the internal organs of the condemned might sometimes be visible after particularly brutal beatings. Soldiers had legal authority to conscript civilians for such labour — reflected elsewhere in Jesus’ phrase "go the extra mile." The traditions about Jesus falling periodically, and the detail about Simon being forced to carry Jesus’ cross, fits known Roman practice.
Jesus (assisted perhaps by Simon) carrying his own the cross through the city is entirely plausible and served Rome's broader deterrent purpose in crucifixion. It made the punishment and its warning visible to as many onlookers as possible. Luke also adds a chilling twist: By the time he was taken to Golgotha, Jesus’ had many supporters on the street who would have been horrified at the spectacle. As the women wailed in sorrow for him Jesus uttered a chilling blessing: “Daughters of Jerusalem do not weep for me but for you and your children…for they will say ‘blessed are the barren, the wombs that never bore and the breasts that never nursed’. They will say ‘Mountains, fall on us…. For if they do this when the wood is green, what will happen when it is dry?” (Luke 23:27-31) The implication was clear. If Rome treats an innocent man like this, what will Rome do to those who take up arms against it? In AD66 the Judeans did take up arms against Rome. The Roman general Titus destroyed Jerusalem and the Temple, with horrific loss of life. Judean Temple worship was also ended, to this day.
Enjoyed this article? John writes regularly about the historical world behind the Maximus novels.